Padecky: Cougars can't believe football season's over


PLEASANT HILL — The game wasn’t over Friday night and yet the comforting had already begun on the Rancho Cotate sideline.

Quarterback Michael Courchaine was holding a grieving wide receiver, Thomas Sory. Injured lineman Shae Smith was consoling running back Jalon Luque. When the game ended, linebacker Ty Brantley slammed his helmet to the ground at the Diablo Valley College stadium. A half-hour after the game ended Rancho players were still sitting on the team bench, heads down. Other players were still on the field, looking, for all the world, lost.

It made sense. Four months of practice and games had just ended. The 2012 Rancho Cotate football team had just played its last game.

Odd as this may read, that last sentence may be the most deflating, bewildering, depressing and basically incomprehensible selection of words those players could read right now.

“We’re all in shock,” Courchaine said of the 35-7 defeat. “I have never felt this pain after I played a sport. It feels like I lost a family member.”

It did no good after the game and it will do no good for the next couple of days for Rancho to read this: Every CIF Division2 team will experience the same fate as the Cougars did Friday night — except for one. That “one” hasn’t been decided yet; there are still two more games to go before a state champion is crowned. But if it makes Rancho feel any better — and it won’t — Clayton Valley could be that state champion.

If Clayton Valley does, it’ll be because of this running back — Joe Protheroe.

Protheroe is an optical illusion. He creates this illusory vision that he is running downhill every time he touches with the ball. He’s a kid who will play at the next level. Among the few positive things the Cougars can take away from Friday’s game was that Protheroe didn’t run all over them as he did other teams this season. He averaged a stunning 15.8 yards a carry during the season but only averaged 4.4 Friday night, gaining just 102 yards on 23 carries. Of course, Protheroe did score four touchdowns, three on rushes and one a 93-yard kickoff return.

The Cougar players, being the proud souls they are, agreed Protheroe was a special player but they stopped short in agreeing as well that Protheroe was that special or that Clayton Valley was that good.

“We came out flat,” said Rancho running back Jalon Luque. “We beat ourselves.”

“They didn’t beat us,” Courchaine said. “We beat ourselves.”

Yes, it is true, Rancho did make the job easier for Clayton Valley. The Cougars turned the ball over five times. The first turnover set the unsettling tone. On the third play of the game Courchaine threw an interception.

“The receiver was open,” Courchaine said. “but I threw behind him. It was a bad throw.”

So, yes, those five turnovers — three of them leading to touchdowns — were Rancho gifts to Clayton Valley. But Clayton Valley had this unmistakable and easily recognizable discipline about itself. They were well-coordinated, well-practiced to a fine 11-man movement. At no time did they ever appear to be rattled or threatened. At no time did Clayton Valley ever appear to be vulnerable.

So in unison were they, it looked like Clayton Valley’s offense was moving forward before the ball was snapped. Rancho coaches brought it to the attention of the game officials who took note. But so disciplined was Clayton Valley, one also could make the case it was an optical illusion, like Protheroe running downhill. However you slice it, the stark conclusion had to be drawn — Clayton Valley had to practice long and hard to be so consistently together when the ball was snapped.

“We got beat,” said Rancho coach Ed Conroy, who had told me earlier this week that “their offense scares me.” The coach was right to be wary. Clayton Valley lays down an aggressive up-tempo push on offense, with direct snaps to ball carriers, some of whom who pitch it outside just before they go inside the tackles.

In the days ahead, it might even take months, the Cougars might eventually see and admit the skill they faced. But right after the game, in which their dream was smashed, when they lost by 28 points, they still weren’t giving up the fight, even if the fight was over. Such is the confidence and determination from a team that’s 12-0 and playing the NCS Division 2 championship.

“Do you believe?” went the chant from inside the team huddle at the end of the third quarter.

“I believe we will win!” came the team response.

Four times that exchange occurred. Four times it was yelled, screamed, from a team that couldn’t, and wouldn’t give it up, even with the score being 35-7 at that point. An undefeated team that is playing on the last day in November doesn’t easily or willingly capitulate.

“This is unreal,” said linebacker Fono Misi. “I thought we were going all the way. I really did.”

So convinced was Misi that Rancho should have won the game, he said, “I’d play them again, right now. This feels so unreal. It makes me angry.”

Angry because Misi and the other seniors felt this year was their time. Rancho had played in the NCS final two years ago, and made the semifinals last year. The Cougars have been close, nudging it hard and this time they felt would be their time, especially the seniors who had experienced the last two NCS games of years past.

“I drilled him (Protheroe) once,” said defensive end A.J. Davidson. “But most of the time I got triple-teamed.”

Most of the time, Davidson felt, he couldn’t do what he wanted to do. Most of the time he felt frustrated. “Most of the time”, well, those words could be applied to the entire team. Most of the time Rancho felt frustrated. Will Rancho remain that way? Of course not. A 12-1 record will be the phoenix for Rancho in the days ahead, rising up to cast its shiny glow. As it should be.

Just as it should have been Friday night, when the players refused to give up, even after the final buzzer. A team doesn’t spend months getting this far by giving up in a matter of seconds, just because the silly game clock says so.

You can reach Staff Columnist Bob Padecky at 521-5223 or